Stop Sending PR Pitches That Will Make Journalists and Bloggers Unfollow You Faster Than Your Ex on Social Media

04 July 2023 Guest Contributor

In the fast-paced world of public relations, effectively pitching stories to the media is crucial for gaining exposure and capturing the attention of journalists and bloggers. However, a poorly crafted PR pitch can have the opposite effect, leading these influential individuals to hit the dreaded "unfollow" button faster than your ex on social media.

To avoid this digital rejection, it's important for PR professionals to understand what makes journalists and bloggers lose interest in a pitch. By avoiding common pitfalls and implementing strategic techniques, you can increase your chances of securing media coverage and maintaining valuable relationships with those who hold significant sway in your industry.

Why PR pitches matter in the digital age

In the digital age, where information is constantly being shared and consumed online, PR pitches have become more important than ever. Journalists and bloggers are bombarded with countless emails every day, making it crucial for PR professionals to craft pitches that capture their attention and stand out from the crowd. Gone are the days when a generic press release would suffice; now, personalisation and relevance are key. 

"...personalisation and relevance are key." 

When crafting a PR pitch in the digital age, it's essential to do your research. Take the time to understand who you're pitching to - what topics they cover, their writing style, and their audience demographics. This will enable you to tailor your pitch accordingly and make it more compelling. Additionally, incorporating multimedia elements like images or videos can help grab attention in an increasingly visual-driven online landscape.

Furthermore, in this era of social media dominance, building relationships with journalists and bloggers is crucial for successful PR outreach. Engage with them on platforms like Twitter or LinkedIn before reaching out with a pitch. This not only helps establish rapport but also allows you to better understand their interests and preferences. Follow these steps while pitching in the digital age of PR to increase your chances of success and prevent getting unfollowed quickly on social media. 

Common mistakes: What not to do

1. Failing to personalise your pitch:

One of the biggest mistakes in PR pitching is sending generic, mass emails to journalists and bloggers. This approach not only shows a lack of effort but also indicates that you haven't taken the time to understand their interests or beat. Instead, take the extra step to research each person you're reaching out to and tailor your pitch accordingly.

Personalisation goes a long way in making your pitch stand out from the hundreds of others flooding their inbox. 

"...research each person you're reaching out to and tailor your pitch accordingly."  

2. Ignoring follow-up etiquette:

Another common mistake is failing to follow up on your initial pitch or doing it incorrectly. While it's important not to be overly persistent, a well-timed follow-up can remind journalists or bloggers about your story idea without being pushy or annoying.

However, avoid sending multiple follow-ups within a short span as this may irritate recipients and harm your chances further. Make sure each follow-up email is short and helpful, providing more information or answering any concerns raised in their previous response (if any). 

"...avoid sending multiple follow-ups within a short span..."   

3. Relying only on press releases:

Sending a press release is an essential part of any PR campaign, but it's not the only one. Journalists receive thousands of emails each day and many are immediately discarded as spam or junk mail.  

"Sending a press release is an essential part of any PR campaign, but it's not the only one."   

Crafting an attention-grabbing subject line

When it comes to pitching your story or product to journalists and bloggers, the subject line of your email is crucial in grabbing their attention. Crafting an attention-grabbing subject line in today's fast-paced digital world can be the deciding factor between having your pitch noticed or being ignored amidst the countless emails flooding everyone's inboxes daily.

To create a subject line that stands out, it's important to avoid generic phrases and clichés. Instead, focus on creating intrigue and curiosity by using specific details about your story or product. For example, rather than saying "New Product Launch," try something like "Revolutionise Your Morning Routine with Our Innovative Coffee Machine." By highlighting a unique feature or benefit of what you're offering, you're more likely to pique the interest of journalists and bloggers. 

"...focus on creating intrigue and curiosity by using specific details about your story or product."  

Another effective strategy is personalisation. Take the time to research the person you're reaching out to and tailor your subject line accordingly. Including their name or referencing something they've recently written about shows that you've done your homework and are genuinely interested in their work. This personalised touch can go a long way in making them more likely to open your email and consider your pitch.

Personalisation and research: Key to success

Tailoring your PR pitches and doing research can help you make effective pitches that won't cause journalists and bloggers to unfollow you on social media. In today's digital age, generic and spammy pitches have lost their charm. Journalists and bloggers receive countless pitches every day, so it's important to stand out from the crowd by tailoring your pitch specifically for each recipient.

The first step towards personalisation is conducting thorough research on the journalist or blogger you're targeting. Take the time to read their previous articles or blog posts, understand their interests, writing style, and preferred topics. This will help you craft a pitch that resonates with them personally and shows that you value their work. 

"The first step towards personalisation is conducting thorough research on the journalist or blogger you're targeting."   

Once you have gathered enough information about your target audience, use this knowledge to customise your pitch accordingly. Address them by name, reference a recent article they wrote or mention why their platform is a great fit for your story idea. Showing authentic curiosity in their work and proving that you have researched about it is a surefire way to capture their attention and avoid joining the dreaded blacklist.

Keep it concise and to the point

1. Avoid lengthy emails or press releases that bury your key message under a mountain of unnecessary details.

Instead, distill your pitch into a few impactful sentences that highlight the most newsworthy aspects of your story.

2. Journalists and bloggers value their time immensely, so respect their busy schedules by keeping your pitches brief and focused.

Make sure to clearly communicate why your story is relevant to their audience and provide compelling evidence or statistics to back up your claims. By delivering a succinct pitch that quickly captures their interest, you increase the chances of forging strong relationships with media professionals who will be eager to work with you in the future.

3. Remember, less is more when it comes to crafting effective PR pitches.

Journalists appreciate concise communication that gets straight to the point without wasting their valuable time. When drafting your next pitch, take the time to condense your message into its most essential elements and cut out any fluff or irrelevant information. By doing so, you'll not only increase the likelihood of capturing media attention but also demonstrate professionalism and an understanding of what journalists truly need from a PR pitch.

Conclusion: Mastering the art of PR pitching

In conclusion, mastering the art of PR pitching requires a comprehensive understanding of the needs and preferences of the journalists and bloggers you're pitching to. So while generic mass emails are a surefire way to get ignored or even blocked, if you take the time to research each recipient's interests and tailor your pitch accordingly, you stand a fighting chance of maintaining a spot in a journalist's inbox. 

Better still, a concise and straight-to-the-point pitch that clearly articulates what you're offering, why it's relevant to their audience and (most importantly) how it can benefit them is a sure-fire way to get to second base.

Lastly, following up appropriately but not excessively through a simple polite email or phone call after an appropriate spell (so not straight away!), can help build long-term relationships with your target media.

Mastering these aspects of PR pitching will greatly increase your chances of success in securing coverage for your brand or client.


PS: Are you receiving FREE publicity opportunities, straight into your inbox?

No?!! (Wha?) 

Let's fix that... right here!